In Musical Fossils, Matthew Hare explores a powerful truth about adult music students: often, the greatest obstacles to learning aren’t aging hands or minds, but the emotional bruises left from childhood education. These early experiences — moments of harsh criticism, humiliation, or pressure to please — leave lasting imprints that make it difficult for adults to learn joyfully and trust themselves in the process.
Hare notes that many successful, highly educated adults struggle with intense self-criticism at the piano. Instead of encouraging themselves, they repeat the judgmental voices of former teachers and parents, undermining their own confidence and creativity. Learning an instrument becomes tangled with fear of making mistakes rather than the pure curiosity and excitement that drive true growth.
In response, Hare advocates for a different teaching philosophy — one built on honest compassion. Corrections must be made, but with empathy for how vulnerable it feels to be wrong, especially for students carrying old educational wounds. Teachers must create spaces where students can safely express frustration, anger, and embarrassment without fear of rejection or ridicule. Rather than suppressing these emotions, acknowledging them can free students to engage more deeply with their learning.
The essay also emphasizes the dangers of traditional schooling systems that replace natural curiosity with the drive to please authority figures. When pleasing the teacher becomes more important than exploring one’s own interests, students lose touch with the joyful instinct to learn for its own sake.
Ultimately, Musical Fossils challenges teachers, parents, and learners to rethink their assumptions about success, mistakes, and self-worth. True musical growth, Hare suggests, doesn’t just come from technical mastery — it comes from reclaiming curiosity, nurturing resilience, and learning to treat ourselves with the kindness we may not have always received.
Summary based on Musical Fossils by Matthew Hare.
Leave a Reply